Guardian Unlimited
Sign in Register
Go to: reports
Home Huttonreport Advertising Television Radio Marketing&PR Press&publishing City
Monkey Newmedia Thisweek Thetenner Talk Specialreports TVratings Jobs

Search this site

Advanced search
Recent articles
Resentment behind Birt attack, say BBC staff

Plan to mount legal challenge abandoned

Dyke set to sign 1m book deal

Dyke signs book deal with Murdoch

BBC 'too commercial' say advertisers

BBC staff to stage protests

Apology to police for Newsnight interview

Birt attacks governors over Iraq report errors

BBC governors told Hutton report was legally flawed

BBC bosses set to blame it all on 'off-piste' Gilligan

Radio| Special report: Iraq - the media war| Special report: the BBC| Television

Kelly: Blair promises public inquiry

Jason Deans
Friday July 18, 2003

Kelly house
Police outside Dr Kelly's house this morning
Tony Blair has promised an independent judicial inquiry if David Kelly has died, journalists travelling with the prime minister on his flight from Washington to Tokyo have said.

His spokesman, Godric Smith, came to the back of the plane less than an hour ago to announce the possible inquiry.

He said a judge would be named this afternoon by the Ministry of Defence.

The development comes as Thames Valley police confirmed the description of the body found near Dr Kelly's home in Oxfordshire matched that of the MoD scientist.

A spokesman confirmed there would be no formal identification until tomorrow.

"We are currently treating this incident as an unexplained death and we will have to wait for the results of the postmortem," he said.

Tony Blair was told of the disappearance of Dr Kelly early this morning and spent much of his flight on the telephone, according to Sky News.

The prime minister's spokesman said he was very concerned for the family of Dr Kelly and promised a public inquiry if his death was confirmed.

"If it is Dr Kelly, there will be a public inquiry, I urge you not to jump to conclusions," said Godric Smith, the prime minister's official spokesman, who is travelling on the plane with Mr Blair.

His comments were reported by the political editor of Sky News, Adam Boulton and by BBC Radio 5.

Alastair Campbell, who usually travels with Mr Blair, is not on the plane - he is on his way back to London.

Mr Smith said he was unable to confirm whether the prime minister has spoken to Mr Campbell but said there was no reason to believe that he had resigned.

"While he understands there will be no formal identification until tomorrow, if it is Dr Kelly the prime minister is obviously very distressed for the family and the Ministry of Defence intends to hold an independent judicial inquiry and there will be an announcement this afternoon as to the name of the judge," Boulton reported.

The MoD said Dr Kelly had at no point been threatened with suspension or dismissal as a result of his admission he had spoken to Gilligan.

It was made clear to Dr Kelly at the time that he had broken civil service rules by having unauthorised contact with a journalist, but "that was the end of it", said a spokesman.

Dr Kelly was given five days to consider his options before the MoD issued its statement on Tuesday July 8 to say an unnamed official had spoken to Gilligan.

And he was given an opportunity to talk through the possible ramifications of going public before the statement was released.

The MoD spokesman said: "He was first interviewed before the weekend and then asked to think about what the options were over the weekend and a decision was taken to say nothing in the meantime.

"He was interviewed again on the Monday and the question of what was the best way forward was talked through with him.

"The contents of the statement were cleared with him before it went out and it was flagged up to him that it was possible his name might get into the public domain at some point and that it was likely the intelligence and security committee and foreign affairs committee would want to take evidence from him."

The spokesman added that the MoD had offered Dr Kelly the use of alternative accommodation to avoid any press attention at his home address.

When he appeared before the committee, Tory MP Sir John Stanley told Dr Kelly he had acted in a "proper and honourable manner" in coming forward to suggest he may have been Gilligan's source but had been "thrown to the wolves" by the Ministry of Defence.

Earlier today a scientist colleague of Dr Kelly said it was because he had so much integrity that he had come forward.

Professor Alistair Hay said the way Dr Kelly had been treated by politicians before the foreign affairs select committee earlier this week was "absolutely inexcusable".

"His whole demeanour during the foreign affairs committee was one of someone who had beaten by the process. I was just so worried by his whole demeanour at the FAC. I just think the pressure is intolerable for someone like him. He is a professional scientist, not somebody who should be a ping pong ball for politicians," Prof Hay told Radio 5 today after police revealed they had found a body near Dr Kelly's home.

Dr Kelly had met Gilligan in the Charing Cross Hotel in central London on May 22, a week before the claim that No 10 had inserted intelligence that Saddam Hussein could launch a chemical or biological weapons strike within 45 minutes was broadcast on the Radio 4 Today programme.

The story has sparked a lengthy and bitter row between the government, the BBC and critics of the war on Iraq.

Dr Kelly told the committee he did not think he could have been the source for the story because Gilligan's account of his conversation with the contact differed from his own version of events.

The foreign affairs committee chairman, Donald Anderson, told Sky News: "On the face of it, this appears to be a human tragedy, if the news is now confirmed, and puts much of the discussion which we have had in a very different and personal perspective."

Later Richard Ottoway, a Tory MP who was on the committee, said he felt the implications of the latest developments were very serious. He said the committee's conclusion that Dr Kelly was unlikely to have been Gilligan's source was flagrantly ignored by No 10, which reacted by saying it was 99% sure Dr Kelly was the BBC reporter's source.

He rejected the idea the committee's questioning of the former weapons inspector had been unduly harsh.

Mr Anderson said there was "no way in which government ministers can be blamed" for the way in which Dr Kelly's name became public.

And he rejected suggestions that the committee should reconvene to consider its position in the light of today's events.

"It is awful, but this is not relevant any more to the work of our committee."

To contact the MediaGuardian newsdesk email or phone 020 7239 9857

18.07.2003: Dr David Kelly
18.07.2003: The Gilligan affair

Related articles
18.07.2003: Body matches Kelly's description
18.07.2003: Kelly's treatment was 'inexcusable', say friends
18.07.2003: Body found in search for MoD 'mole'
18.07.2003: 'BBC mole' reported missing
18.07.2003: Profile: Dr David Kelly
18.07.2003: MPs accuse Gilligan of changing story
17.07.2003: BBC row with government deepens
16.07.2003: Tory leader attacks government 'deceit'
15.07.2003: Mole casts doubt on MoD claims
15.07.2003: Kaufman calls for BBC press ban
16.07.2003: MPs say scientist not BBC source
14.07.2003: Is Phil Bassett the new Alastair Campbell?
12.07.2003: Speculation grows over Campbell
10.07.2003: MPs will question MoD arms consultant
10.07.2003: Scientist named as BBC contact
09.07.2003: Short attacks 'bully' Campbell
09.07.2003: Hoon names MoD 'mole' in move BBC brands a farce
09.07.2003: BBC rejects deal on naming dossier source
09.07.2003: BBC chairman's letter to Geoff Hoon
08.07.2003: MoD man admits he met Gilligan
08.07.2003: Dyke urges Campbell to bury hatchet
08.07.2003: Ex-Campbell aide blasts 'salacious' BBC
08.07.2003: Not guilty verdict may not prevent an eventual exit
07.07.2003: BBC hits back over Straw demand for apology
07.07.2003: Humphrys: we were right
07.07.2003: Bury the hatchet, say PR chiefs
07.07.2003: MPs demand investigation of Gilligan contacts
07.07.2003: Report justifies BBC, says corporation
07.07.2003: Campbell cleared of doctoring Iraq dossier
07.07.2003: BBC and government in stalemate
07.07.2003: Governors back BBC in row over Iraq dossier
07.07.2003: Robin Cook: Blair was wrong
07.07.2003: Experts sceptical about pre-war Saddam threat
06.07.2003: Blair stakes reputation in battle with BBC
06.07.2003: MI6 chief briefed BBC over Iraq arms fears
05.07.2003: Dyke summoned to BBC crisis meeting
04.07.2003: No 10 challenges BBC over Hoon interview
04.07.2003: Study deals a blow to claims of BBC anti-war bias
04.07.2003: Dossier not 'sexed up' say MPs
03.07.2003: Top BBC journalists lash out at Sun
03.07.2003: Letter reveals Campbell's role in intelligence dossier
01.07.2003: BBC offers olive branch to No 10
30.06.2003: Minister unrepentant in Gilligan row
30.06.2003: Dossier debacle: the questions left unanswered
29.06.2003: BBC set to sue minister over Iraq 'lies' claim
28.06.2003: BBC takes dossier fight to Campbell
28.06.2003: Master of spin storms studio to become the story
27.06.2003: BBC defiant over Campbell attack
27.06.2003: BBC stands firm in Iraq row
27.06.2003: Straw promises 'decisive evidence' in Iraq row
27.06.2003: BBC scorns Campbell deadline for apology
26.06.2003: No 10 steps up row with BBC
26.06.2003: BBC hits back in Iraq row
26.06.2003: Campbell claims BBC lied
25.06.2003: BBC stands by Gilligan over Campbell claims
25.06.2003: Campbell lambasts BBC over Iraq 'lies'

Reports, statements and letters
07.07.2003: Report on Gilligan and Campbell
Full text of report
07.07.2003: Report at a glance
07.07.2003: Full text of BBC governors' statement
27.06.2003: Sambrook's letter to Campbell: full text

Andrew Gilligan's 'sexed up' dossier broadcast
27.06.2003: Extracts from his report on BBC Radio 4's Today

Comment and analysis
16.07.2003: Simon Hoggart: Whisper of confusion tells its own story
09.07.2003: Patrick Wintour: BBC plays cards close to its chest
09.07.2003: Matt Wells: How BBC saw trickery in Hoon deal
08.07.2003: Matt Wells: BBC back to business in bullish mood
08.07.2003: Lance Price: 'Alastair did not lie'
08.07.2003: Leader: Ministerial sauce
07.07.2003: Rod Liddle: Why the BBC was right
07.07.2003: Tom Happold: Judgment day
07.07.2003: Peter Preston: It's a charade and we all know it
04.07.2003: Matt Wells: Trading blows over the culture of cynicism
04.07.2003: Letters: Single source of BBC discontent
04.07.2003: Justin Lewis: Biased broadcasting corporation
30.06.2003: Peter Preston: Why don't they look for the mole?
27.06.2003: BBC v Downing Street: what the papers said
30.06.2003: Nicholas Jones: Campbell exposed
29.06.2003: Kamal Ahmed: War of the words
28.06.2003: Richard Norton-Taylor: BBC row obscures ugly truth
29.06.2003: Peter Beaumont: The BBC reported what we were all told
30.06.2003: Roy Hattersley: The voters do not like bullies
28.06.2003: Leader: Labour's phoney war

Andrew Gilligan
27.06.2003: Tough reporter who has riled No 10
05.06.2003: Thorn in flesh of Downing Street
05.06.2003: Gilligan defends Iraq report

Press review
07.07.2003: July 7: what the papers said
30.06.2003: June 30: what the papers said special reports
Iraq: the media war

Printable version | Send it to a friend | Save story

UP Guardian Newspapers Limited 2003